Should You Go to Urgent Care, Your Primary Care Doctor, or the Emergency Room?

A man in his early 40s sits by himself in the waiting room of a medical clinic
If you’re sick or injured, it can be difficult to know whether you should visit a walk-in urgent care center, your primary care doctor, or the emergency room. Choosing the right place for same-day care can help you receive treatment more quickly while ensuring you get the care you need.

Ryan Renacci, MD, MA, Medical Director, Mount Sinai-Urgent Care, East 14th Street, explains when each option is most appropriate.

a headshot of Ryan Renacci, MD, MA

Ryan Renacci, MD, MA

What is the difference between urgent care and the emergency room?

Emergency rooms, also known as emergency departments, are primarily for patients with life-threatening conditions, such as a stroke or major injury. Urgent care centers provide walk-in, same-day care for common illnesses and minor injuries that are not life-threatening.

Emergency rooms have greater resources to evaluate and treat more serious or complex conditions. They can perform laboratory testing and imaging quickly, provide rapid interpretation of results, and consult specialists if emergency intervention is needed.

Because lab results at urgent care are not available the same day, patients with symptoms such as chest pain, abdominal pain, or dizziness that could be related to a heart condition, blood clot, or stroke may be referred to the emergency room, where timely diagnosis and treatment are critical.

What conditions can be treated at an urgent care center?

Urgent care centers provide same-day care for many illnesses and injuries that require prompt treatment but are not medical emergencies, including:

Common illnesses

  • Upper respiratory infections, including strep throat
  • Flu symptoms
  • Urinary tract infections
  • Bronchitis
  • Mild coughs
  • Rashes

Minor injuries

  • Sprains and strains
  • Ankle injuries
  • Fractures of the arm or leg
  • Minor head injuries and concussions
  • Cuts requiring stitches or suture removal

Other services

  • Vaccinations
  • Routine blood tests
  • Screening laboratory tests
  • Evaluation for sexually transmitted infections

The help desk at Mount Sinai-Urgent Care, East 14th Street

The reception desk at Mount Sinai-Urgent Care, East 14th Street, located in Mount Sinai-Union Square


When should I go to the emergency room instead of urgent care?

Go to the emergency room immediately if you have symptoms of a heart attack, stroke, severe bleeding, major trauma, or another life-threatening emergency. If you are unsure whether your condition is an emergency, an urgent care provider can evaluate you and refer you to the emergency department if necessary.

What are some common misconceptions about urgent care?

A common misconception is that urgent care is the right place for ongoing, chronic, and complex medical problems. While urgent care is good for evaluating new symptoms that have developed over a few days, specialists are better equipped to monitor chronic illnesses, adjust medications, and manage more complex conditions over time.

Signs You Should Call 911

Examples:

  • Chest pain with shortness of breath
  • Sudden weakness or numbness
  • Difficulty speaking
  • Severe head injury
  • Loss of consciousness
  • Severe bleeding
  • Accidental drug ingestion or overdose

When should I see a doctor instead of going to urgent care?

If you are experiencing chronic or ongoing health problems, you should see a specialist. For example, chronic hearing loss or chronic hearing changes should be evaluated by an ear, nose, and throat (ENT) specialist. Persistent or complex skin rashes should be managed by a dermatologist, who can offer medications, perform biopsies, and provide specialized care. Similarly, changes or refills to chronic medications (like blood pressure medications) should always be performed by your primary care physician, who can monitor you over time.

What should I do if I can’t get an appointment with my primary care doctor?

If you cannot get a timely appointment with your primary care doctor, urgent care can provide same-day care for many non-emergency medical concerns while helping coordinate follow-up with a specialist or primary care doctor, often within a few days.

What You Should Know About Perimenopause—the Time Before Menopause

Night sweats. Hot flashes. These are the symptoms that most women associate with menopause. However, many women experience these—and other symptoms that they may not recognize as related to menopause—for as many as 10 years before the onset of menopause.

In this Q&A, Kumi Yuki, MD, Director of Mount Sinai’s Virtual Primary Care for Menopause, discusses what you should know and what you can do about symptoms related to perimenopause—the time before menopause.

“It’s important for women to educate themselves about perimenopause. But it’s equally important to make sure that your sources of information are reputable,” Dr. Yuki says. “Social media and word of mouth may not be your best sources of information. Whenever you are going through something you don’t understand, it’s best to speak with your doctor.”

What should women know about perimenopause?

There is an interesting recent study that highlights the fact that many women don’t associate the symptoms they are experiencing as part of perimenopause. While physical changes such as hot flashes, weight gain, and sleep disturbances are widely recognized, other prevalent symptoms like fatigue, brain fog, mood swings, and anxiety often go overlooked.

Kumi Yuki, MD

Women in their 40s and 50s often don’t know what’s going on with their bodies because no one teaches them “this is menopause.” In a sense, it’s like having their first menstrual period, because their body is going through a change for the first time that they have never experienced. And if women are still having their period, they may not associate these symptoms with the gradual changes of perimenopause. It is essential that we address this knowledge gap through targeted education to empower women and promote their overall wellness during this transition.

What are some common symptoms of perimenopause that women might overlook?

There are a number of symptoms, including:

  • Pain during sexual intercourse and vaginal dryness
  • Joint pain and fatigue
  • Brain fog, irritability, mood changes, and anxiety

Women may not realize that this transition into menopause affects the whole body—and mind. Many women may experience symptoms and not associate them with a transition their body is going through. Sometimes, these mood changes may occur around the menstrual cycle and may make it easier to realize the cause, but not always. Many women may not seek treatment and try to push through on their own.

Why is virtual care for perimenopause a good option?

Virtual primary care for menopause increases access and convenience. Often, same-day appointments are available, whereas that’s usually not possible with a gynecologist. If a patient has questions about the way they are feeling, or has basic questions about perimenopause, virtual care provides a great entry point for care. A patient can test the waters, find out options for evaluation and treatment, and start their personal path to managing their symptoms. If a case is more complex, they can see their gynecologist for in-person care. No matter what you are feeling, it is always good to talk to a health care professional because there are options for care.

For the Grill: Heart-Healthy Chicken Burger

Double Stack Mushroom and Chicken Cheeseburgers

INGREDIENTS

1 lb cremini mushrooms
1 lb ground chicken (or ground turkey)
Salt, to taste
Pepper, to taste
Oil, to coat pan
4 slices cheese, of your choice
4 buns or rolls
1 red or yellow onion, sliced and grilled (optional)
Pickles (optional)
Toppings, of your choice

PREPARATION

Lightly salt the mushrooms. Add them to a food processor and pulse until finely chopped, or chop fine by hand. Mix chopped mushrooms and ground poultry in a large bowl until well combined. Divide mixture into 8 equal parts and form into 8 thin patties; season the patties lightly with salt and pepper. Transfer to a plate and set aside.

Lightly coat a large skillet or grill pan with the oil. Add the patties and cook 5 to 6 minutes per side. Top each patty with a slice of with the cheese of your choice, and heat briefly, and possibly cover the pan, to melt the cheese.

Stack 2 patties on each bun and top with grilled onion slices, pickles or other toppings of your choice.

Playing Pickleball This Summer? Protect Your Joints With These Simple Stretches

With Mount Sinai Sports Medicine Doctor James N Gladstone, MD, Medical Advisor to the U.S. Davis Cup tennis team

Nutritional Information per serving (without bun or cheese)
Approximately 247 calories
Carbohydrates: 35.5 g
Protein: 18.4 g
Fat: 4.6 g
4 servings

I love to cook, and I am always searching for new recipes.  My family enjoys a good burger, but we don’t eat a lot of meat and prefer poultry. I found this recipe online, and have made it multiple times for my immediate family and guests. It’s always a hit. The mushrooms really create a “meaty” flavor. –Sandy Sterthous, Recruiter, Human Resources

Two Mount Sinai Brooklyn Nurses Are Grateful for Their Start as Patient Care Associates

From left: Beth Oliver, DNP, RN, FAAN; Melissa James, BSN; Claudia Garcenot, MSN, MHA, RN; and Nicole Jones, BSN

Melissa James, RN, began her career in health care as a patient care associate (PCA) at Mount Sinai Brooklyn in 2015, but nursing school was always in her plan.  It was also in the family, as Melissa’s mother began her own health care career as a certified nursing assistant, eventually becoming a licensed practical nurse.

In fact, Melissa’s mother encouraged her to become a PCA in order for her to test the waters and make sure nursing was the right path.  Melissa quickly decided it was, and began saving for her nursing education. She attended Long Island University part-time during the day for five years, while continuing to work at Mount Sinai Brooklyn, at times covering both evening and morning shifts, in addition to scribing for a local medical office.

”It was challenging,“ she says, “but doable. My family and work colleagues were tremendously supportive.  And after 16-hour days while I was a student, my current 12-hour shift is a breeze.”

Melissa says her experience as a PCA was invaluable training for a career in nursing.

“It was like having clinical rotations before even starting nursing school. As a PCA, I spent a lot of time at the bedside, which really helped me develop strong patient communication skills, something that might have taken longer had I gone straight into nursing,” she says. “While I’m still very much involved with patients as an RN, the nature of my role has changed. There are certain hands-on tasks I no longer perform as often, but I now have the opportunity to apply critical thinking and collaborate with fellow nurses and the medical team to develop treatment plans.”

Melissa is on the same unit, 2 East, as she was as a PCA. “My unit is special. If you stick your head out the door asking for assistance, people come running,” she says. “We are all committed to helping one another. 2 East works as a team! And, we are a fun, friendly group.”

Nicole Jones, BSN, began her health care journey as a patient care associate at Mount Sinai Brooklyn in 2020. Like Melissa, she always knew she wanted to become a nurse. And she previously majored in Science as an undergraduate. In 2023, she took the next step by enrolling in the accelerated BSN program at the Mount Sinai Phillips School of Nursing.

“Balancing part-time work with the intensity of a 15-month program was challenging, but the support at PSON made all the difference,” she says. “The faculty truly wanted us to succeed—tutoring was accessible, and the close-knit environment made it easy to build strong relationships with both faculty and classmates.”

After graduating in 2024, Nicole started her nursing career in February 2025 at Mount Sinai Brooklyn’s Stepdown Progressive Care Unit, where she cares for patients transitioning from surgery or the Intensive Care Unit (ICU).

“I absolutely love being a nurse and having the autonomy to make decisions in patient care,” she says. “Working as a PCA really shaped me—it not only taught me to prioritize safety and strengthened my appreciation for bedside care, but also prepared me for the demands of nursing school by enhancing my clinical awareness and time-management skills.”

Nicole, like Melissa, is focused on the present but remains open to what the future holds. “I’m considering the ICU as a potential next step to grow clinically, but I’m also interested in pursuing wound care—both areas really speak to different parts of my nursing passion,” she says. “It feels good to be in a place where there are so many meaningful directions to explore.”

Live Post Test

Undergoing Maintenance

We will Be back Soon

This is an example of a blank page with no header or footer.

Standard Maintenance

Divi is here to stay, and you can rest easy knowing that our team will be updating and improving it for years to come.

Feature Updates

Divi is here to stay, and you can rest easy knowing that our team will be updating and improving it for years to come.

Bug Fixes

Divi is here to stay, and you can rest easy knowing that our team will be updating and improving it for years to come.

Nice Going!

Alert to Signs of a Stroke, Mount Sinai Queens Nurse Helps Save a Colleague

From left: Vanessa Rose Jayme, MS, RN; Daniella Stephen, MPH, MSN, RN; Anne Pisciotta, RN; Asha Cox, RN; Connie Vargas, Director of Nursing Systems; Riskarlyn Figuereo; and Sharon Kurian, MSN, RN, CMSRN, Assistant nurse manager, 3 East

Asha Cox, RN, Nurse Manager on 4 East at Mount Sinai Queens, started her day recently by checking on a nurse in her unit who had experienced an injury earlier in the week. Calling the nurse at home, Asha immediately detected that something was wrong. She said to her colleague, “Your voice has changed, are you okay?”  Within moments, Asha knew this nurse was not well.  “It was also clear she was alone in her home.  I told her to call 911, but she could not.  I asked for her address, but it was hard to understand her, so the next step was to look through the Mount Sinai database to find where she lived and how to reach her emergency contact.  I also told her to unlock the door for emergency services, if she could do so safely. And to lie on the floor to avoid falling.“

Thankfully, colleagues were in the office, and it became a team effort. Daniella Stephen, MPH, MSN, RN, Senior Director, was by Asha’s side, offering guidance. Riskarlyn Figuereo, Administrative Office Coordinator, searched through the database for the emergency contact information and home address. Anne Pisciotta, Clinical Nurse Manager, 3 West, was a calming presence with her frequent nods of support.  And Vanessa Rose Jayme, MS, RN, Assistant Nurse Manager, came just in time to offer her telephone for multitasking while Asha spoke to her colleague and the 911 operator simultaneously. “I was feeling in control, but when 911 called back to say they could not find the entrance to her building, admittedly I had to work a little harder to calm my nerves,” Asha says.

Safiya Alozie, RN, Nurse Manager, 3 East, was in the office as well. “As we listened, the voice over the phone gradually became more slurred and disoriented,” Safiya says. “Asha remained calm, soothing her colleague and reassuring her that help was on the way. We heard the cries and the fear through the phone, and the anxiety among us all was palpable. The 15-minute phone call seemed liked an hour. But Asha never showed any fear, reminding this nurse that she would not hang up until the ambulance arrived. When we all heard the medical team burst through the door, there was a sense of relief for everyone. We could finally exhale!”

Asha, who has worked as a nurse at the Mount Sinai Health System for 18 years, says her experience was key in helping her navigate this “somewhat surreal” situation. “As nurses, we learn how to pay attention to seemingly little things, the details, an unusual symptom,” Asha explains. “In this case, I picked up on her voice, and the longer she was on the phone, I recognized the signs of stroke.”  She adds, “You cannot be sure how you will respond in times like these, but I am a person of faith. I am also am so thankful that my colleagues were close by. I felt supported.”

Jill Goldstein, MA, MS, RN, Vice President, Patient Services, and Deputy Chief Nurse Officer, Mount Sinai Queens, says: “Asha exceeded the definition of hero this day. She followed her intuition and her heart, which led to the successful 911 intervention. This is emblematic of Asha’s leadership style, authentic, transformational and dedicated to her staff and colleagues. We are blessed to work with Asha.”